If you ignore this, you’ll regret it later. Trust me, narcissists have a knack for faking empathy, and if you’re not careful, you might miss the signs. Sure, they can say all the right things, but their body language is where the truth leaks out. Today, we’ll dive into the eight reasons why narcissists fake empathy.
Are you ready for number one? To mirror you and build false rapport. Have you ever felt like someone was trying just a little too hard to be in sync with you? Narcissists are experts at pretending to connect, but it’s all a game. They mirror your emotions, behaviors, and body language to make you think they understand you better than anyone. The goal is to manipulate and build a false sense of rapport. It’s like they’re using a script from a bad acting class, where smiles are delayed, nods are exaggerated, and their expressions are just off.
Dr. Ramani Durvasula, a psychologist and expert on narcissism, explains that this tactic isn’t just for show; it’s designed to gain your trust and control your reactions. Narcissists thrive on making others feel like they’re seen, but only in ways that benefit them. It makes you unsure of whether the connection is real or just another performance.
Now, let’s talk about number two: to appear emotionally intelligent. Narcissists know that showing empathy makes them look deep and evolved, but in reality, it’s a facade. They love to appear emotionally intelligent because it gives them an edge in social or professional settings. They can say all the right things about understanding and caring, but their body often gives them away.
Dr. Carol McBride, a therapist who specializes in narcissistic abuse, points out that narcissists often have micro-expressions—tiny, almost imperceptible changes in their facial expressions that reveal the truth. It’s when a brief smirk flashes across their face while you’re sharing something painful, or their eyebrow raises just a bit too much while they’re listening. They’re trying to act like they care, but their face forgot to read the script.
Sharing is caring!
Let’s move on to number three: to extract information. Have you ever felt like someone was listening to you too intently, as if they were waiting for you to say something specific? Narcissists know that if they appear caring and interested, you’ll open up and share things that you might not normally reveal. However, they’re not just collecting facts for the sake of understanding; instead, they store this information like emotional ammunition, ready to use it against you when the time is right.
Psychologist Dr. Julie Smith explains that this is a classic narcissistic tactic—gathering intel for manipulation. Watch their body language carefully; they might lean in a bit too close, their eyes scanning you like they’re on a fact-finding mission—not connecting with you, but sizing you up. They’re mentally taking notes while you think you’re having a genuine conversation.
Now, let’s continue to number four: to avoid accountability. Have you ever noticed how someone can apologize without actually apologizing? Narcissists are masters at avoiding accountability. When they say, “I’m so sorry; I didn’t realize it hurt you,” it sounds like an apology, but it’s just a clever way to deflect blame without taking any real responsibility. They want you to believe they’re owning up to their actions, but deep down, they’re only worried about covering their own tracks.
Psychologist Dr. Linda Martinez-Louie notes that narcissists often use this tactic to avoid facing the consequences of their behavior while still maintaining their innocent image. You can spot the signs in their body language: crossed arms, a clenched jaw, or tapping fingers—all signs of defensiveness. Their posture practically shouts, “I’m not responsible for this,” even as their words claim the opposite. It’s like they’re trying to tell you they’re sorry, but their body is sending a very different message.
You shouldn’t miss number five: to one-up your pain. Narcissists will start by pretending to empathize, giving you just enough attention to make you think they care, but then they quickly shift the focus to their own experiences, often exaggerating them to make your pain seem insignificant. It’s not about understanding your feelings, but about winning a pity contest.
Sharing is caring!
According to Dr. Ramani Durvasula, narcissists use others’ pain as a way to maintain control and feel superior. Their body language often gives them away: think exaggerated sighs, fake tears, and clutching their chest as if they’re in the middle of an Oscar-worthy performance. It’s a tactic to keep the spotlight on them, manipulating your empathy while subtly undermining your progress. Instead of offering support, they make you feel like you’re the one who should be consoling them. As soon as you show vulnerability, they seize the opportunity to turn the tables, and before you know it, you’re comforting them, wondering how you got caught up in their emotional games.
Are you still up for number six? To love-bomb you. Narcissists use love-bombing to reel you in fast, and fake empathy is a big part of that act. They want to hook you before you have time to think, pulling out all the stops in the early stages of the relationship. It’s not real affection, though; it’s manipulation.
As Dr. Sherry Stein, a clinical psychologist who specializes in narcissistic abuse, points out, “Love-bombing is a way for narcissists to create dependency. They overload you with praise, attention, and affection, leaving you dizzy with confusion.” If you pay attention to their body language, you’ll notice everything is over the top: constant, intense eye contact, dramatic head tilts, and overly touchy gestures. It’s all about creating the illusion of love and connection just to secure their place in your life.
But as time goes on, their true intentions will start to show through. The affection they shower you with slowly turns into control, and the empathy they express quickly fades away. So if everything feels a little too perfect, take a step back and watch for the cracks in the facade.
Let’s keep it moving to number seven: to disarm you during a confrontation. When narcissists are caught in a lie or called out for their bad behavior, their go-to tactic is fake concern. They’ll soften their tone and say, “I’m so sorry you feel that way,” to make you lower your defenses, but it’s all just a cover-up.
According to Dr. Craig Malkin, a clinical psychologist and author of Rethinking Narcissism, this is a manipulative move to shift the focus off their wrongdoing and make you feel guilty instead. If you pay attention to their body language, though, the truth leaks out. While their words are sweet, their body is tense: clenched fists, tight lips, or narrowed eyes. It’s a classic case of using charm as a shield while preparing for their next emotional move.
Sharing is caring!
They’re skilled at making you doubt your own feelings, but these subtle cues reveal that their apology is more about controlling the situation than showing real remorse. When their body doesn’t match their words, it’s a clear sign that you’re dealing with manipulation, not empathy. Don’t let their act fool you; watch for the hidden signals.
Finally, we’re down to number eight: to manipulate therapy sessions. In a therapist’s office, narcissists will fake emotional awareness, throwing out lines like, “I validate your feelings,” while sneakily checking if the therapist is buying it. It’s emotional manipulation disguised as maturity.
Psychologist Dr. Robin Stern, author of The Gaslight Effect, calls this behavior strategic empathy—a calculated performance to shift blame and earn sympathy. You start doubting yourself because they’re so convincing in front of others, and you fear speaking your truth in therapy might just backfire. It’s not healing; it’s a hostage situation with throw pillows. Therapy should feel safe, but for you, it can feel like stepping into a courtroom where the narcissist plays the misunderstood saint. Meanwhile, you’re left wondering if anyone will truly see the manipulation behind the performance. Their goal is to leave you feeling confused, unsure of what’s real, and questioning your own sanity. It’s a twisted game of emotional chess, and you might be losing without even knowing it.
So the next time a narcissist gives you their best “I’m so caring” act, pay attention to their body language. It’s often the little things that tell you the real story. Trust your instincts, and let their actions—not just their words—guide your understanding.
Sharing is caring!
